These views were expressed at a workshop on Pune model of zero loadshedding organised by the Institution of Engineers to mark its golden jubilee. Jayant Deo, managing director and chief executive officer (CEO) of Indian Energy Exchange presided over the workshop.

Addressing the gathering, Shantanu Dixit of Prayas energy group said that though they had earlier estimated 150 MW as sufficient energy to keep Pune free from load-shedding, MSEDCL increased this requirement to 304 MW. "There is no scientific basis and justification for the revised demand stated by the MSEDCL. We first need to establish the exact requirement of power for Pune," he said.

Dixit also pointed out that even TPTCL has failed to supply 150 MW power from October 1 onwards despite making an advance contract at an average rate of Rs 8.54 per unit. "Tata power has been able to supply only 45 MW to 90 MW per day and we need to be vigilant and see if the franchisee is honouring its agreement," he said.

Dixit felt that the success of Pune model has taught us that the society can solve its problems if its different sections, like consumer organisations and industry bodies come together to find solutions. "It has also taught us that consumers have to be extremely vigilant in the entire process," he added.

Vivek Velankar, founder of Sajag Nagrik Manch, charged that it was carelessness on MSEDCL's behalf and its failure to forecast the demand and supply correctly that has hindered the smooth functioning of the Pune model. "MSEDCL had admitted in its own affidavit, filed before the Nagpur bench of the Bombay high court, that some of its officials were not following the load shedding protocol and had to be pulled up," he said.